Close up of a diamond and emerald necklace representing valuables at risk of theft during home showings.

Real Stories Of Theft During Showings And How To Prevent It

Theft During A Home Showing: What Sellers Need To Know

Every now and then, a story surfaces that leaves homeowners shocked at theft that can happen during a showing. Recently, I came across a post on Reddit where a homeowner shared how a bottle of wine was stolen during a showing of their multi-million-dollar home. You can read the full post here.

This was not just any showing. The homeowners had spent over two years renovating and staging the property to perfection. After several showings, they realized a bottle of Belle Glos pinot noir had gone missing. The doorbell camera later revealed a guest slipping the bottle into a bag. What made it worse was the response afterward. The buyer’s agent refused to confront the buyer, fearing it might cost him a high-value listing down the road. Needless to say, the sellers were left feeling betrayed and violated.

Why Sellers Must Assume The Unexpected

As upsetting as this story is, it serves as an important reminder. When you open your home for showings, you are inviting strangers inside. Some may bring friends, family, or even children. It is impossible to know everyone’s intentions.

Over the years, I have seen or heard of all sorts of things going missing and various theft that has occurred. Sometimes it is small items, like a candy jar. Other times it is heartbreaking, like family heirlooms or expensive jewelry. I have even had clients report pharmaceuticals being taken, including one case where someone swiped antibiotics meant for the family dog.

The truth is, real estate agents do their best to watch over the home during showings, but they cannot keep eyes on every guest at every moment. It is simply not possible, especially when multiple people attend a showing.

Protecting Your Valuables During A Showing

The lesson here is clear. If something has value to you, do not leave it out during showings. This does not just apply to jewelry or cash. Even bottles of wine, prescription medications, and sentimental items should be put away or removed from the home altogether.

Some of the best steps you can take include:

  • Removing valuables and storing them at a friend’s house
  • Using a safe deposit box for especially valuable items
  • Taking smaller valuables with you when you leave for a showing
  • Using a small portable container to carry jewelry, watches, or other personal items with you during showings

It may feel inconvenient, but it is far better than dealing with the loss of something valuable or irreplaceable.

Final Thoughts

Stories like the stolen wine bottle may seem unbelievable, but they are real and they happen more often than many sellers realize. Do not assume every guest in your home has good intentions. Protect yourself, protect your valuables, and be smart when preparing for showings.

If you are planning to sell your home and want advice on how to protect yourself during the process, I would be happy to share more tips and even connect you with trusted real estate professionals across the country.

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Alex Powell
Alex Powell

Hi, I’m Alex. I spent 25 years helping people buy and sell homes as a residential real estate expert. After building and eventually selling my own real estate brokerage business, I shifted gears. These days, I focus on what I find most rewarding: helping people make smart, confident decisions about real estate through unbiased advice and real-world insight. I’ve guided thousands of people through the process of buying and selling, and I bring that experience to every article, recommendation, and conversation. When I’m not writing or answering questions, I enjoy staying active, traveling, and keeping an eye out for new investment opportunities.